← Back to browse

Data Visualization Support for Tumor Boards and Clinical Oncology: Protocol for a Scoping Review

Stage 1 article

AuthorsDominik BoehmCosima StrantzJan ChristophHauke BuschThomas GanslandtPhilipp Unberath
Year2024
VenueJMIR Research Protocols
Item typeJournal Article

Background: Complex and expanding data sets in clinical oncology applications require flexible and interactive visualization of patient data to provide the maximum amount of information to physicians and other medical practitioners. Interdisciplinary tumor conferences in particular profit from customized tools to integrate, link, and visualize relevant data from all professions involved. Objective: The scoping review proposed in this protocol aims to identify and present currently available data visualization tools for tumor boards and related areas. The objective of the review will be to provide not only an overview of digital tools currently used in tumor board settings, but also the data included, the respective visualization solutions, and their integration into hospital processes. Methods: The planned scoping review process is based on the Arksey and O’Malley scoping study framework. The following electronic databases will be searched for articles published in English: PubMed, Web of Knowledge, and SCOPUS. Eligible articles will first undergo a deduplication step, followed by the screening of titles and abstracts. Second, a full-text screening will be used to reach the final decision about article selection. At least 2 reviewers will independently screen titles, abstracts, and full-text reports. Conflicting inclusion decisions will be resolved by a third reviewer. The remaining literature will be analyzed using a data extraction template proposed in this protocol. The template includes a variety of meta information as well as specific questions aiming to answer the research question: “What are the key features of data visualization solutions used in molecular and organ tumor boards, and how are these elements integrated and used within the clinical setting?” The findings will be compiled, charted, and presented as specified in the scoping study framework. Data for included tools may be supplemented with additional manual literature searches. The entire review process will be documented in alignment with the PRISMA-ScR (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for Scoping Reviews) flowchart. Results: The results of this scoping review will be reported per the expanded PRISMA-ScR guidelines. A preliminary search using PubMed, Web of Knowledge, and Scopus resulted in 1320 articles after deduplication that will be included in the further review process. We expect the results to be published during the second quarter of 2024. Conclusions: Visualization is a key process in leveraging a data set’s potentially available information and enabling its use in an interdisciplinary setting. The scoping review described in this protocol aims to present the status quo of visualization solutions for tumor board and clinical oncology applications and their integration into hospital processes. Trial Registration:

Tags

JMIRStage 1 Manuscript

Other

AuthorsDominik BoehmCosima StrantzArsenij UstjanzewIryna ManuilovaAlexander ScheiterThomas PauliNicole HechtelNiklas ReimerJan ChristophHauke BuschThomas GanslandtPhilipp Unberath
Year2025
VenueJournal of Medical Internet Research
Item typeJournal Article

Background: Complex and expanding datasets in clinical oncology applications require flexible and interactive visualization of patient data to provide physicians and other medical professionals with maximum amount of information. In particular, interdisciplinary tumor conferences profit from customized tools to integrate, link, and visualize relevant data from all professions involved. Objective: Our objective was to identify and present currently available data visualization tools for tumor boards and related areas. We wanted to provide an overview of not only the digital tools currently used in tumor board settings but also of the data they include, their respective visualization solutions, and their integration into hospital processes. Methods: This scoping review was based on the scoping study framework by Arksey and O’Malley and attempted to answer the following research question: “What are the key features of data visualization solutions used in molecular and organ tumor boards, and how are these elements integrated and used within the clinical setting?” The following electronic databases were searched for articles: PubMed, Web of Science, and Scopus. Articles were deemed eligible if published in English in the last 10 years. Eligible articles were first deduplicated, followed by screening of titles and abstracts. Full-text screening was then conducted to decide on article selection. All included articles were analyzed using a data extraction template. The template included a variety of meta-information, as well as specific fields aiming to answer the research question. Results: The review process started with 2049 articles, of which 1014 (49.49%) were included in the title and abstract screening. A total of 5.47% (112/2049) of the publications were eligible for full-text screening, leading to 2.93% (60/2049) of the publications being eligible for final inclusion. They covered 49 distinct visualization tools and applications. We discovered a variety of innovative visualization solutions, most often driven by the complexity of omics data, represented in 96% (47/49) of the tools. Tables remained the most used tool for the visualization of data types described in the articles. Approximately one-third of the identified tools (16/49, 33%) were systematically evaluated in some form. For most discovered tools (37/49, 76%), there was no documentation of implementation into the clinical routine. A significant number of applications (21/49, 43%) were available through open-source access. Conclusions: There is a wide range of projects providing visualization solutions for tumor boards and clinical oncology applications. Among the few tools that have made their way into clinical routine settings, there are both commercial and academic solutions. While tables for a variety of data types remain the dominant visualization strategy, the complexity of omics data appears to be the driving force behind many visualization innovations in the domain of tumor boards. Trial Registration:

Tags

JMIRJMIR: DE Data ExistingStage 1 LinkedStage 2 Manuscript